Once, she laughed without meaning to.
Another time, she wiped her cheek angrily.
At seventeen, Carl had apparently stopped trying to make his absence sound noble.
Lily read one line aloud.
“‘For years, I told myself staying away was the one decent thing I had done. I’m old enough now to understand that sometimes cowardice simply learns better language for itself.’”
She lowered the page.
I said nothing.
The letters did not magically turn Carl into a good father.
They didn’t erase missed birthdays.
They didn’t replace thirteen Christmas mornings.
They didn’t give Lily back all the nights she had waited for a phone call that never came.
If anything, the letters made things more complicated.
Because now we knew Carl had cared.
And sometimes knowing someone cared while still choosing to stay away hurts more than believing they felt nothing.
Eventually Lily placed the final letter on the table.