His face changed.
And suddenly, I understood.
He was not looking at my tattoo and thinking about me.
He was thinking about Claire’s.
Natalie had already connected Claire to the butterfly on her shoulder.
Every time she saw my tattoo, there was a chance tattoos would become a topic again.
There was a chance she would mention “the butterfly lady” in front of me.
Rob had not been disgusted.
He had been scared.
I asked him one final time for his phone.
Again, he refused.
That night, I slept in another room.
Over the following days, Rob insisted that the kiss had been a single mistake.
He apologized, begged me not to throw away our marriage, and promised nothing else had happened.
But I could not get past the lies.
He had lied about Claire.
He had lied about the kiss.
He had let me believe my tattoo was destroying our marriage when he knew exactly what was really threatening it.